«BULLETIN OF THE IRKUTSK STATE UNIVERSITY. GEOARCHAEOLOGY, ETHNOLOGY, AND ANTHROPOLOGY SERIES»
ISSN 2227-2380 (Print)

List of issues > «Geoarchaeology, Ethnology, and Anthropology Series». 2022. Vol 41

Chronology of the Pleistocene Finds of Homo Remains in Siberia: Results and Problems (A Short Overview)

Full text (russian)

Author(s)
Y. V. Kuzmin
Abstract
This overview article contains a brief critical analysis of the chronology of Late Pleistocene and Early Holocene finds of Homo remains in Siberia. Direct dating of the Homo bones and teeth, as well as the isolation and analysis of the ancient human DNA, has now become firmly established in the practice of paleoanthropological research. About 62% of the Late Pleistocene and Early Holocene Siberian Homo remains have information on ancient DNA and direct dates of the bones and teeth. Particular attention is given to the assessment of the reliability of ages determined by the radiocarbon dating method. Information on the taphonomy (conditions and process of burial and fossilization) of Homo remains in the caves of the Mountain Altai is also of great importance. At present, three species of Pleistocene Homo are known in Siberia: Denisovans, Neanderthals, and anatomically modern humans (Homo sapiens). For the DenisovanNeanderthal hybrid, there is a direct date obtained by the Uranium series method, which shows the age of 67,500 cal BP. The age of other Denisovan fossils cannot be precisely determined due to the significant mixing of layers in Denisova Cave. The timing of the Denisovans in Siberia can be preliminarily determined at 130,000–44,000 cal BP (the upper limit is very approximate). The age of Siberian Neanderthals is greater than 50,000 cal BP; it is difficult to be more precise due to the widespread disturbance of the Altai caves’ stratigraphy by the burrowing activity of animals, primarily cave hyenas. Early Homo sapiens inhabited Siberia from 45,000 cal BP to the Early Holocene. No clear correspondence can be observed between climate changes in the second half of the Late Pleistocene (45,000–12,000 cal BP) and the chronology of Homo sapiens in Siberia. The age of some Homo sapiens fossils (Baigara, Solovyinaya Luka, and Sibiryachikha 6) after direct dating turned out to be much younger than initially expected. The taxonomic status of some Siberian Homo (Tuyana; an individual from the Okladnikov Cave with a date of 28,300 cal BP) has not yet been reliably identified. Obviously, it is necessary to increase the number of direct dates for Siberian hominins.
About the Authors
Kuzmin Yaroslav Vsevolodovich, Doctor of Sciences (Geography), Leading Researcher, Sobolev Institute of Geology and Mineralogy SB RAS, 3, academician Koptyug Avenue, Novosibirsk, 630090, Russian Federation, e-mail: kuzmin@fulbrightmail.org
For citation
Kuzmin Y. V. Chronology of the Pleistocene Finds of Homo Remains in Siberia: Results and Problems (A Short Overview) . Bulletin of the Irkutsk State University. Geoarchaeology, Ethnology, and Anthropology Series. 2022, Vol. 41, pp. 31–42. https://doi.org/10.26516/2227-2380.2022.41.31 (in Russ.)
Keywords
Siberia, Homo, Denisovans, Neanderthals, anatomically modern humans, chronology, paleoclimate.
UDC
57.075+572.42+902.652+903.52+903.59(571)
DOI
https://doi.org/10.26516/2227-2380.2022.41.31
References

Akimova E., Higham T., Stasyuk I., Buzhilova A., Dobrovolskaya M., Mednikova M. A new direct radiocarbon AMS date for an Upper Palaeolithic human bone from Siberia. Archaeometry. 2010, Vol. 52, pp. 1122–1130.

Bergström A., Stringer C., Hajdinjak M., Scerri E. M. L., Skoglund P. Origins of modern human ancestry. Nature. 2021, Vol. 590, pp. 229–237.

Curtis G. H., Swisher C. C. III, Lewin R. Java Man. How Two Geologists’ Dramatic Discoveries Changed Our Understanding of the Evolutionary Path to Modern Humans. London, Little, Brown and Co., 2001, 256 p.

Dikov N. N. Verkhnii paleolit Kamchatki [The Upper Paleolithic of Kamchatka]. Sovetskaya arkheologiya [Soviet Archaeology]. 1969, Is. 3, pp. 93–109. (In Russ.)

Dikov N. N. Paleolit Kamchatki i Chukotki v svyazi s problemoi pervonachalnogo zaseleniya Ameriki [The Paleolithic of Kamchatka and Chukotka in connection with the problem of the initial peopling of America]. Magadan, SVKNII DVO RAN Publ., 1993, 68 p. (In Russ.)

Douka K., Slon V., Jacobs Z., Ramsey C. B., Shunkov M. V., Derevianko A. P., Mafessoni F., Kozlikin M. B., Li B., Grün R., Comeskey D., Devièse T., Brown S., Viola B., Kinsley L., Buckley M., Meyer M., Roberts R. G., Pääbo S., Kelso J., Higham T. Age estimates for hominin fossils and the onset of the Upper Palaeolithic at Denisova Cave. Nature. 2019, Vol. 565, pp. 640–644.

Fu Q., Li H., Moorjani P., Jay F., Slepchenko S. M., Bondarev A. A., Johnson P. L. F., Aximu-Petri A., Prüfer K., de Filippo C., Meyer M., Zwyns N., Salazar-Garcìa D. C., Kuzmin Ya. V., Keates S. G., Kosintsev P. A., Razhev D. I., Richards M. P., Peristov N. V., Lachmann M., Douka K., Higham T. F. G., Slatkin M., Hublin J.-J., Reich D., Kelso J., Viola T. B., Pääbo S. The genome sequence of a 45,000-year-old modern human from western Siberia. Nature. 2014, Vol. 514, pp. 445–450.

Gerasimova M. M., Astakhov S. N., Velichko A. A. Paleoliticheskii chelovek, ego materialnaya kultura i prirodnaya sreda obitaniya [Paleolithic human, its material culture and natural environment of habitation]. St. Petersburg, 2007, 240 pp. (In Russ.)

Hublin J.-J. How old are the oldest Homo sapiens in Far East Asia? Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA. 2021, Vol. 118, p. e2101173118. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2101173118

Hublin J.-J. The modern human colonization of western Eurasia: when and where? Quaternary Science Reviews. 2015, Vol. 118, pp. 194–210.

Jacobs Z., Bo L., Shunkov M. V., Kozlikin M. B., Bolikhovskaya N. S., Agadjanian A. K., Uliyanov V. A., Vasiliev S. K., O’Gorman K., Derevianko A. P., Roberts R. G. Timing of archaic hominin occupation of Denisova Cave in southern Siberia. Nature. 2019, Vol. 565, pp. 594–599.

Keates S. G., Kuzmin Y. V., Burr G. S. Chronology of Late Pleistocene humans in Eurasia: results and perspectives. Radiocarbon. 2012, Vol. 54, pp. 339–350.

Khaldeeva N. I., Vasiliev S. V., Akimova E. V., Vasiliev A. Yu., Drozdov N. I., Kharlamova N. V., Zorina I. S., Petrovskaya V. V., Perova N. G. Kompleksnoe antropologicheskoe issledovanie nizhnei chelyusti s pozdnepaleoliticheskoi stoyanki Listvenka [Complex anthropological study of the mandible from the Late Paleolithic site of Listvenka]. Arkheologiya, etnografiya i antropologiya Evrazii [Archaeology, Ethnology and Anthropology of Eurasia]. 2016, Vol. 44, Is. 1, pp. 147–156. (In Russ)

Kılınç G. M., Kashuba N., Yaka R., Sümer A. P., Yüncü E., Shergin D., Ivanov G. L., Kichigin D., Pestereva K., Volkov D., Mandryka P., Kharinskii A., Tishkin A., Ineshin E., Kovychev E., Stepanov A., Alekseev A., Fedoseeva S. A., Somel M., Jakobsson M., Krzewińska M., Storå J., Götherström A. Investigating Holocene human population history in North Asia using ancient mitogenomes. Scientific Reports. 2018, Vol. 8, p. 8969. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-018-27325-0

Kiryushin Y. F., Kungurov A. L., Tishkin A. A., Shpakova E. G. Mestonakhozhdenie Soloviinaya Luka [The site Soloviinaya Luka]. Problemy arkheologii, etnografii, antropologii Sibiri i sopredelnykh territorii [Problems of Archaeology, Ethnography, Anthropology of Siberia and the neighboring territories]. 2000, Vol. 16, pp. 147–155. (In Russ.)

Kolobova K., Krivoshapkin A. Comment on “Upper Paleolithic site Tuyana – A multi-proxy record of sedimentation and environmental history during the Late Pleistocene and the Holocene in the Tunka rift valley, Baikal region [Quat. Int. 534 (2019) 138–157]”. Quaternary International. 2022 (in press). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.quaint.2020.08.012

Krause J., Orlando L., Serre D., Serre D., Viola B., Prüfer K., Richards M. P., Hublin J.-J., Hänni C., Derevianko A. P., Pääbo S. Neanderthals in central Asia and Siberia. Nature. 2007, Vol. 449, pp. 902–904.

Kuzmin Ya. V. The Siberian Late Pleistocene mammal fossils in numerical perspective: review of Christy G. Turner II, Nicolai D. Ovodov and Olga V. Pavlova. Animal Teeth and Human Tools: A Taphonomic Odyssey in Ice Age Siberia. 2013. Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press. Radiocarbon, 2014, Vol. 56, Is. 2, pp. xi–xvi.

Kuzmin Ya. V. Rasselenie rannikh lyudei sovremennogo tipa (Homo sapiens sapiens) v Evrazii: sovremennoe sostoyanie voprosa [The settlement of modern humans (Homo sapiens sapiens) in Eurasia: current state of the issue]. Ekologiya drevnikh i traditsionnykh obshchestv [Ecology of the ancient and traditional societies]. Tyumen, 2016, Is. 5, Part 1, pp. 119–122. (In Russ)

Kuzmin Ya. V. Geoarkheologiya: estestvennonauchnye metody v arkheologicheskikh issledovaniyakh [Geoarchaeology: natural science methods in archaeological studies]. Tomsk, 2017, 395 pp. (In Russ.)

Kuzmin Ya. V. Radiouglerodnaya khronologiya lyudei sovremennogo anatomicheskogo tipa epokhi paleolita Vostochnoi Evropy, Sibiri i Vostochnoi Azii [Radiocarbon chronology of anatomically modern humans of the Paleolithic epoch in Eastern Europe, Siberia and East Asia]. Camera praehistorica. 2020, Is. 2 (5), pp. 122–146. (In Russ)

Kuzmin Ya. V., Dikova M. A. Khronologiya pozdnepleistotsenovykh arkheologicheskikh pamyatnikov SeveroVostochnoi Sibiri: sostoyanie voprosa (2014 g.) [Chronology of the Late Paleolithic archaeological sites of Northeastern Siberia: state of the issue (2014)]. Rossiiskii arkheologicheskii ezhegodnik [Russian archaeological annual]. 2014, Is. 4, pp. 8–22. (In Russ)

Kuzmin Ya. V., Keates S. G. Direct radiocarbon dating of Late Pleistocene hominids in Eurasia: current status, problems, and perspectives. Radiocarbon. 2014, Vol. 56, pp. 753–766.

Kuzmin Ya. V., Keates S. G. The chronology of hominin fossils from the Altai Mountains, Siberia: an alternative view. Journal of Human Evolution. 2020, Vol. 146, p. 102834.

Kuzmin Ya. V., Kosintsev P. A., Razhev D. I., Hodgins G. W. L. The oldest directly-dated human remains in Siberia: AMS 14C age of talus bone from the Baigara locality, West Siberian Plain Journal of Human Evolution. 2009, Vol. 57, pp. 91–95.

Kuzmin Ya. V., Slavinsky V. S., Tsybankov A. A., Keates S. G. Denisovans, Neanderthals, and early modern humans: a review of the Pleistocene hominin fossils from the Altai Mountains (Southern Siberia). Journal of Archaeological Research. 2022, Vol. 30, pp. 321–369.

Kuzmin Ya. V., Orlova L. A., Zenin V. N., Lbova L. V., Dementiev V. N. Radiouglerodnoe datirovanie paleolita Sibiri i Dalnego Vostoka Rossii: materialy k katalogu 14C dat (po sostoyaniyu na konets 2010 g.) [Radiocarbon dating of the Paleolithic in Siberia and the Russian Far East: materials to the catalog of 14C dates (for the end of 2010)]. Stratum plus. 2011, Is. 1, pp. 171–200. (In Russ)

Lee E. J., Merriwether D. A., Kasparov A. K., Khartanovich V. I., Nikolskiy P. A., Shidlovskiy F. K., Gromov A. V., Chikisheva T. A., Chasnyk V. G., Timoshin V. B., Pavlova E. Y., Pitulko V. V. A genetic perspective of prehistoric hunter-gatherers in the Siberian Arctic: mitochondrial DNA analysis of human remains from 8000 years ago. Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports. 2018, Vol. 17, pp. 943–949.

Mafessoni F., Grote S., de Filippo C., Slon V., Kolobova K. A., Viola B., Markin S. V., Chintalapati M., Peyrégne S., Skov L., Skoglund P., Krivoshapkin A. I., Derevianko A. P., Meyer M., Kelso J., Peter B., Prüfer K., Pääbo S. A high-coverage Neandertal genome from Chagyrskaya Cave. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA. 2020, Vol. 117, pp. 15132–15136.

Pavlenok G. D., Zubova A. V. Novye dannye o nositelyakh selenginskoi paleoliticheskoi kultury (Zapadnoe Zabaikaliye) [New data about the bearers of the Selenga Paleolithic culture]. Arkheologiya, etnografiya i antropologiya Evrazii [Archaeology, Ethnology and Anthropology of Eurasia]. 2019, Vol. 47, Is. 3, pp. 3–11. (In Russ)

Raghavan M., Skoglund P., Graf K. E., Metspalu M., Albrechtsen A., Moltke I., Rasmussen S., Stafford Jr. T. W., Orlando L., Metspalu E., Karmin M., Tamberts K., Rootsi S., Mägi R., Campos P. F., Balanovska E., Balanovsky O., Khusnutdinova E., Litvinov S., Osipova L. P., Fedorova S. A., Voevoda M. I., DeGiorgio M., Sicheritz-Ponten T., Brunak S., Demeshchenko S., Kivisild T., Villems R., Nielsen R., Jakobsson M., Willerslev E. Upper Palaeolithic Siberian genome reveals dual ancestry of Native Americans. Nature. 2014, Vol. 505, pp. 87–91.

Razhev D. I., Kosintsev P. A., Kuzmin Y. V. Pleistotsenovaya tarannaya kost (os talus) cheloveka s mestonakhozhdeniya Baigara (tsentr Zapadnoi Sibiri) [Pleistocene bone (os talus) of human from the Baigara locality (center of Western Siberia)]. Vestnik arkheologii, antropologii i etnografii [Bulletin of Archaeology, Anthropology and Ethnography]. 2010, Is. 1 (12), pp. 119–131. (In Russ.)

Reich D., Green R. E., Kircher M., Krause J., Patterson N., Durand E. Y., Viola B., Briggs A. W., Stenzel U., Johnson P. L. F., Maricic T., Good J. M., MarquesBonet T., Alkan C., Fu Q., Mallick S., Li H., Meyer M., Eichler E. E., Stoneking M., Richards M., Talamo S., Shunkov M. V., Derevianko A. P., Hublin J.-J., Kelso J., Slatkin M., Pääbo S. Genetic history of an archaic hominin group from Denisova Cave in Siberia. Nature. 2010, Vol. 468, pp. 1053–1060.

Seierstad I. K., Abbott P. M., Bigler M., Bluiner T., Bourne A. J., Brook E., Buchardt S. L., Buizert C., Clausen H. B., Cook E., Dahl-Jensen D., Davies S. M., Guillevic M., Johnsen S. J., Pedersen D. S., Popp T. J., Rasmussen S. O., Severinghaus J. P., Svensson A., Vinther B. M. Consistently dated records from the Greenland GRIP, GISP2 and NGRIP ice cores for the past 104 ka reveal regional millennial-scale 18O gradients with possible Heinrich event imprint. Quaternary Science Reviews. 2014, Vol. 106, pp. 29–46.

Shchetnikov A. A., Bezrukova E. V., Matasova G. G., Kazansky A. Yu., Ivanova V. V., Danukalova G. A., Filinov I. A., Khenzykhenova F. I., Osipova E. M., Berdnikova N. E., Berdnikov I. M., Rogovskoi E. O., Lipnina E. A., Vorobyeva G. A. Upper Paleolithic site Tuyana – a multi-proxy record of sedimentation and environmental history during the Late Pleistocene and Holocene in the Tunka rift valley, Baikal region.Quaternary International. 2019, Vol. 534, pp. 138–157.

Shpakova E. G. Odontologicheskie materialy perioda paleolita na territorii Sibiri [Odontological materials of the Paleolithic period in Siberia]. Arkheologiya, etnografiya i antropologiya Evrazii [Archaeology, Ethnology and Anthropology of Eurasia]. 2001, Vol. 4 (8), pp. 64–76. (In Russ.) Shpakova E. G., Derevianko A. P. Interpretatsiya odontologicheskikh osobennostei pleistotsenovykh nakhodok iz peshcher Altaya [Interpretation of odontological peculiarities of the Pleistocene finds from the cave in Altai Monutains]. Arkheologiya, etnografiya i antropologiya Evrazii [Archaeology, Ethnology and Anthropology of Eurasia]. 2000, Is. 1, pp. 125–138. (In Russ.)

Sikora M., Pitulko V. V., Sousa V. C., Allentoft M. E., Vinner L., Rasmussen S., Margaryan A., de Barros Damgaard P., de la Fuente Castro C., Renaud G., Yang M., Fu Q., Dupanloup I., Giampoudakis K., Bravo Nogues D., Rahbek C., Kroonen G., Peyrot M., McColl H., Vasilyev S. V., Veselovskaya E., Gerasimova M., Pavlova E. Y., Chasnyk V. G., Nikolskiy P. A., Grebenyuk P. S., Fedorchenko A. Yu., Lebedintsev A. I., Slobodin S. B., Malyarchuk B. A., Martiniano R., Meldgaard M., Arppe L., Palo J. U., Sundell T., Mannermaa K., Putkonen M., Alexandersen V., Primeau C., Mahli R., Sjögren K.-G., Kristiansen K., Wessman A., Sajantila A., Mirazon Lahr M., Durbin R., Nielsen R., Meltzer D. J., Excoffier L., Willerslev E. The population history of northeastern Siberia since the Pleistocene. Nature. 2019, Vol. 570, pp. 182–188.

Skoglund P., Mathieson I. Ancient genomics of modern humans: the first decade. Annual Review of Genomics and Human Genetics. 2018, Vol. 19, pp. 381–404.

Skov L., Peyrégne S., Popli D., Iasi L. N. M., Devièse T., Slon V., Zavala E. I., Hajdinjak M., Sümer A. P., Grote S., Bossoms Mesa A., López Herráez D., Nickel B., Nagel S., Richter J., Essel E., Gansauge M.,Schmidt A., Korlević P., Comeskey D., Derevianko A. P., Kharevich A., Markin S. V., Talamo S., Douka K., Krajcarz M. T., Roberts R. G., Higham T., Viola B., Krivoshapkin A. I., Kolobova K. A., Kelso J., Meyer M., Pääbo S., Peter B. M. Genetic insights into the social organization of Neanderthals. Nature. 2022, Vol. 610, pp. 519–525.

Slon V., Viola B., Renaud G., Gansauge M.-T., Benazzi S., Sawyer S., Hublin J.-J., Shunkov M. V., Derevianko A. P., Kelso J., Prüfer K., Meyer M., Pääbo S. A fourth Denisovan individual. Science Advances. 2017, Vol. 3, p. e1700186. https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.1700186

Turner C. G. II. Paleolithic teeth of the Central Siberian Altai Mountains. Chronostratigraphy of the Paleolithic in North, Central, East Asia and America. Novosibirsk, 1990, pp. 239–243.

Turner C. G. II, Ovodov N. D., Pavlova O. V. Animal Teeth and Human Tools: A Taphonomic Odyssey in Ice Age Siberia. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2013, 490 pp.

Vasiliev S. V., Borutskaya S. B., Rogovskoi E. O., Berdnikova N. E., Lipnina E. A., Berdnikov I. M. Soobshchenie ob antropologicheskikh nakhodkakh na paleoliticheskom mestonakhozhdenii Tuyana v Tunkinskoi riftovoi doline (Yugo-Zapadnoe Pribaikaliye) [Report about the anthropological finds at the Paleolithic locality of Tuyana in the Tunka rift valley (southwestern Transbaikalia)]. Izvestiya Irkutskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Seriya Geoarkheologiya. Etnologiya. Antropologiya [Bulletin of the Irkutsk State University. Geoarchaeology, Ethnology, and Anthropology Series]. 2017, Vol. 22, pp. 150–165. (In Russ.)

Yang M. A., Fu Q. Insights into modern human prehistory using ancient genomes. Trends in Genetics. 2018, Vol. 34, pp. 184–196.

Yu H., Spyrou M. A., Karapetian M., Shnaider S., Radzevičiūtė R., Nägele K., Neumann G. U., Penske S., Zech J., Lucas M., LeRoux P., Roberts P., Pavlenok G., Buzhilova A., Posth C., Jeong C., Krause J. Paleolithic to Bronze Age Siberians reveal connections with first Americans and across Eurasia. Cell. 2020, Vol. 181, pp. 1–14, June 11, 2020. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cell.2020.04.037

Zavala E. I., Jacobs Z., Vernot B., Shunkov M. V., Kozlikin M. B., Derevyanko A. P., Essel E., de Fillipo C., Nagel S., Richter J., Romagné F., Schmidt A., Li B., O’Gorman K., Slon V., Kelso J., Pääbo S., Roberts R. G., Meyer M/ Pleistocene sediment DNA reveals hominin and faunal turnovers at Denisova Cave. Nature. 2021, Vol. 595, pp. 399–403.

Zubova A. V., Krivoshapkin A. I., Shalagina A. V. Paleoantropologicheskie materialy iz peshchery Strashnoi na Gornom Altae v kontekste odontologicheskoi differentsiatsii naseleniya Sibiri epokhi kamnya [Paleoanthropological materials from the Strashnaya Cave in Mountainous Altai in the context of odontological differentiation of the population of Siberia in the Stone Age].Arkheologiya, etnografiya i antropologiya Evrazii [Archaeology, Ethnology and Anthropology of Eurasia]. 2017, Vol. 45, Is. 3, pp. 136–145. (In Russ.)

Zubova A. V., Stepanov A. D., Kuzmin Y. V. Comparative analysis of a Stone Age human tooth fragment from Khaiyrgas Cave on the Middle Lena (Yakutia, Russian Federation). Anthropological Science. 2016, Vol. 124, pp. 135–143.