Methodological Studies of G. I. Medvedev

E. B. Volosova

List of issues > «Geoarchaeology, Ethnology, and Anthropology Series». 2023. Vol 44

Methodological Studies of G. I. Medvedev

Full text (russian)

Author(s)

E. B. Volosova

Abstract

The article deals with the methodological concept of the Siberian archaeologist G. I. Medvedev. The central element of his thoughts was the analysis of the features of the archaeological material. He thought quite original for his time, questioning the main thesis of Soviet archaeology about an archaeological object as an objective source of sociohistorical information. The artifact indicates only the fact of the activity and the time of stay of the subjects of the ancient society, and also provides information about the “physically reliable” parameters. It turns out that any social reconstructions, even of the functions of fossil artifacts, are conjectural, and sometimes fantastic. The rationale for this conclusion is based on an understanding of the specific conditions for the formation of artifacts. This conclusion logically led to the interest of Medvedev, a scientist and methodologist, in the question of how to ensure the reliability of the knowledge produced by archaeologists. His research in this area led him to the project “geoarchaeology”. Medvedev's methodological concept has been formed for several decades and has been presented in scientific papers of different years. In the 1970s, the author and a group of like-minded people in the archaeological laboratory of the Irkutsk State University accumulated experience in conducting morphological and technological studies of stone and ceramics, offered justification for their compliance with the features of archaeological sites. In the candidate's and then doctoral dissertations, practical experience was collected and comprehended, some theoretical ideas were formulated. Even then, Medvedev identified two areas of his research – geoarchaeological and cultural-historical, dividing them not only by subject, but also by the degree of reliability of the results. In the 1990s and 2000s, there was a comprehension and theoretical formulation of the concept of geoarchaeology, which Medvedev considered as a condition for overcoming the difficulties of archaeological knowledge, achieving reliability, objectivity, and reliability of the knowledge produced. The elements of this concept can be considered the definition of geoarchaeology as a science, the definition of its subject area and cognitive boundaries, the analysis of geoarchaeological objects and directions of their study, the identification of the structure and methods of research, the concept of “recognition threshold”, the steps of presenting the author's conclusions.

About the Authors

Volosova Evgeniya Borisovna, Candidate of Sciences (Philosophy), Associate Professor, Department of Philosophy and Methodology of Science, Irkutsk State University; 1, K. Marx st., Irkutsk, 664003, Russian Federation, e-mail: volosova1961@rambler.ru

For citation

Volosova E. B. Methodological Studies of G. I. Medvedev. Bulletin of the Irkutsk State University. Geoarchaeology, Ethnology, and Anthropology Series. 2023, Vol. 44, pp. 87–98. https://doi.org/10.26516/2227-2380.2023.44.87 (in Russ.)

Keywords

methodology of archaeological science, geoarchaeology, object, threshold of recognition, reliability of knowledge.

UDC

902/904:1(47)(092)

DOI

https://doi.org/10.26516/2227-2380.2023.44.87

References

Gening V. F. Obiekt i predmet nauki v arkheologii [Object and subject of science in Archaeology]. Kiev, Nauka Dumka Publ., 1983, 223 p. (In Russ.)

Goryunova O. I., Saveliev N. A. Opyt razrabotki ponyatii dlya opisaniya form sosudov neoliticheskoi i rannebronzovoi keramiki Vostochnoi Sibiri [Experience in developing concepts for describing vessel shapes of Neolithic and Early Bronze Age ceramics of Eastern Siberia] Opisanie i analiz arkheologicheskikh istochnikov [Description and analysis of archaeological sources]. Irkutsk, 1981, pp. 115–125. (In Russ.)

Grigoriev G. P. O predmete arkheologii [About the subject of Archaeology]. Opisanie i analiz arkheologicheskikh istochnikov [Description and analysis of archaeological sources]. Irkutsk, 1981, pp. 3–15. (In Russ.)

Kononova T. N., Medvedev G. I., Parkhomenko Yu. S. K uporyadochivaniyu opisaniya chopperov [On ordering the description of choppers] Arkheologiya. Ehtnografiya. Istochnikovedenie: tezisy dokladov [Archaeology. Ethnography. Source studies: abstracts of reports]. Irkutsk, 1979, pp. 59–62. (In Russ.)

Lipnina E. A., Medvedev G. I. O protsessakh mekhanicheskoi obrabotki kamnya rasshchepleniem v paleolite–neolite Srednei Sibiri [On the processes of mechanical processing of stone by splitting in the Paleolithic– Neolithic of Central Siberia]. Problemy arkheologii i ehtnografii Sibiri i Dalnego Vostoka, posvyashchennoe 100-letiyu N. K. Auerbakha. Kratkoe soderzhanie dokladov [Problems of Archaeology and Ethnography of Siberia and the Far East, dedicated the 100th anniversary of N. K. Auerbach. Summary of the reports]. Krasnoyarsk, 1991, Vol. 2, pp. 8–11. (In Russ.)

Medvedev G. I. K probleme morfologicheskogo analiza kamennogo inventarya paleoliticheskikh i mezoliticheskikh ansamblei Vostochnoi Sibiri [On the problem of morphological analysis of stone inventory of Paleolithic and Mesolithic ensembles of Eastern Siberia]. Opisanie i analiz arkheologicheskikh istochnikov [Description and analysis of archaeological sources]. Irkutsk, 1981, pp. 16–33. (In Russ.)

Medvedev G. I. Paleolit Yuzhnogo Priangariya : avtoref. dis. … d-ra ist. nauk [Paleolithic of the Southern Angara region. Doc. histor. sci. syn. diss.]. Novosibirsk, 1983, 44 p. (In Russ.)

Medvedev G. I. Geoarkheologiya. Syuzhety istorii formirovaniya [Geoarchaeology. Plots of the history of formation]. Antropogen, paleoantropologiya, geoarkheologiya, ehtnologiya Azii [Anthropogen, Paleoanthropology, Geoarchaeology, Ethnology of Asia]. Ikutsk, 2008, pp. 133–155. (In Russ.)

Medvedev G. I., Volosova E. B. O termine "osvoenie" i nekotorykh problemakh arkheologicheskogo poznaniya (geoarkheologicheskii aspekt) [On the term "development" and some problems of archaeological cognition (geoarchaeological aspect] Istoricheskii opyt osvoeniya vostochnykh raionov Rossii: Tezisy dokladov i soobshcheniya mezhdunarodnoi nauchnoi konferentsii [Historical experience of the development of the eastern regions of Russia: abstracts and reports of the international scientific conference]. Vladivostok, 1993, pp. 56–61. (In Russ.)

Medvedev G. I., Alaev S. N., Alaeva T. N. Opyt primeneniya polevoi fiksatsionnoi kartochki na paleoliticheskikh mestonakhozhdeniyakh [Experience of using field fixation cards on Paleolithic sites] Arkheologiya i ehtnografiya Vostochnoi Sibiri: Tezisy dokladov k regionalnoi konferentsii [Archaeology and Ethnography of Eastern Siberia: abstracts for the regional conference]. Irkutsk, 1978, pp. 85–86. (In Russ.)

Medvedev G. I., Saveliev N. A., Lezhnenko I. L. Modelirovanie i tekhnologicheskaya klassifikatsiya reztsov i skrebkov [Modeling and technological classification of cutters and scrapers] Opisanie i analiz arkheologicheskikh istochnikov [Description and analysis of archaeological sources]. Irkutsk, 1981, pp. 104–115. (In Russ.)

Medvedev G. I., Generalov A. G., Kuznetsov M. F., Lastochkin S. V., Saveliev N. A., Berdnikova N. E., Vorobieva G. A., Dneprovsky Yu. I., Dneprovskaya L. V., Lipnina E. A. K probleme ponimaniya arkheologicheskikh obiektov, ikh izucheniya i sokhraneniya na territorii Irkutskoi oblasti (geoarkheologicheskii aspekt) [On the problem of understanding archaeological sites, their study and preservation on the territory of the Irkutsk region (geoarchaeological aspect)]. Istoriko-kulturnoe nasledie Vostochnoi Sibiri: nauchnoprakticheskaya konferentsiya [Historical and cultural heritage of Eastern Siberia: scientific and practical conference]. Irkutsk, 1994, pp. 3–7. (In Russ.)

Medvedev G. I., Saveliev N. A., Berdnikova N. E., Alaeva T. V., Vorobieva G. A., Mukhkharamov Sh. Z., Rebrikov P. N., Kuznetsov M. F., Lastochkin S. V., Dneprovsky Yu. I., Volosova E. B., Dneprovskaya L. V., Osadchy S. S. Geoarkheologicheskie issledovaniya: metodika, praktika, innovatsii [Geoarchaeological research: methodology, practice, innovations] Vybiraet "Zolotoi medved": Tezisy dokladov konkursa uchenykh vuzov Irkutskoi oblasti ["The Golden Bear" Project: Thesis of the competition of scientists of universities of the Irkutsk region]. Irkutsk, 1995, pp. 56. (In Russ.)

Medvedev G. I., Generalov A. G., Drozdov N. I., Lbova L. V., Akimova E. B., Berdnikova N. E., Vetrov V. M., Vorobieva G. A., Goryunova O. I., Zaika A. L., Lastochkin S. V., Lipnina E. A., Makulov V. I., Osadchy S. S., Oschepkova E. B., Saveliev N. A., Tashak E. V. Problemy nauchnoi ehkspertizy i praktiki izucheniya geoarkheologicheskikh obiektov Baikalskoi Sibiri: (metodologiya, metody, rekomendatsii) [Problems of scientific expertise and practice of studying geoarchaeological objects of Baikal Siberia: (methodology, methods, recommendations)]. Krasnoyarsk, Irkutsk, Ulan-Ude, Arkom Publ., 1996, 53 p. (In Russ.)

Sbornik uchebnykh programm po spetsializatsii "Arkheologiya, ehtnologiya". Seriya "kafedra – student" [Collection of curricula for the specialization "Archaeology, Ethnology". The series "department to the student»]. Irkutsk, Ottisk Publ., 2005, 72 p. (In Russ.)

Vorozhtsov V. P., Moskalenko A. T., Shubina M. P. Gnoseologicheskaya priroda i metodologicheskaya funktsiya nauchnoi teorii [Epistemological nature and methodological function of scientific theory]. Novosibirsk, Nauka Publ., 1990, 186 p. (In Russ.)